Pie is hard.
Oh sure, it’s got this reputation as this working-class, farmer’s wife, set out on the window sill to cool, egalitarian reputation.
Yeah, it’s a big fat lie. I don’t know who the marketing genius was behind this brilliant campaign, but they earned their paycheck plus a big, fat bonus.
Don’t get me wrong, pie is delicious. Made by the right hands, it is an awesome hug from a freshly baked grandma. But those hands are few and far between. Because pie is a full-on culinary minefield, where each step can take hope and twist it into shame. Every procedure has the potential to become misshapen disappointment.
And that’s just the crust.
Crust is the high school crush of pie—there are just so many ways to go wrong. You can overwork the dough and get rubber. If you don’t let it rest and chill, it’ll shrink and slide down the pie dish. You might overcook the edges and undercook the bottom. Who amongst us has had a delicious filling and raw bottom? I know I have.
Then there are the innards.
Too wet, too dry, too sweet, not sweet enough. Meringue that is both too wet and too dry. Too much filling, too little. Weird texture, weird flavor. Fruit that tastes like it was canned during World War II, and may or may not contain botulism.
Like I said Gentle Reader, it’s a minefield out there. So, we’ll try to break it down, and demystify and de-scarify it a touch.
Pie crust or any baked good containing wheat, barley, rye, triticale, and oats have gluten. Think of gluten as spandex. This is what gives bread the ability to rise so much and become airy and chewy.
But in just about every other application, you don’t want to promote gluten. It will make the product dense and rubbery. And this includes pie crust.
There are two remedies. The first is to cut the water in the pastry with alcohol. Water will cause gluten to develop. Hooch will not. Many folks use vodka because it has no flavor. But why waste an opportunity to add flavor?
The second way to avoid gluten development is vital. Add liquor or not, but if you overwork the dough, it’s over.
Work the dough just, and I mean just, until it starts coming together. You actually want to see pea-size lumps of butter in the finished dough, if it’s a homogeneous mass, it’s over.
Here is the recipe for a cornmeal piecrust The Kid invented in culinary school. Next week, I promise I’ll be much less long-winded (as if) and give you the recipes for two different ways to fill it.
Thanks for your time.
Contact debbie at firstname.lastname@example.org.
The Kid’s 1-2-3 Cornmeal Pastry Crust
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 tsp salt
2 teaspoons sugar
8 ounces (2 sticks) salted butter, frozen then grated on the large holes, place on parchment, and put back in freezer for 30 minutes
¼ cup ice-cold liquor like rum or whiskey
½ cup ice cold water (approximately)
Put the first four ingredients into bowl of food processor. Pulse three times to mix. Add butter and pulse twice until butter’s just mixed in.
Add alcohol and a tablespoon of water. Pulse twice, and if it hasn’t come together add a bit more water, pulse once, and check again. When it barely holds together, turn out onto plastic wrap. Using the wrap, bring all the loose pieces into the whole, divide if making a two-crust into separate rounds and refrigerate for at least an hour.
Or refrigerate for up to five days, or freeze up to 2 months.